The detailed gear stressing is the key of this paper. Pdf hertz contact stress analysis and validation using finite. Buckling calculations are done for central load euler. Hertz contact theory hct is a study of contact stress and. That creates a new face to hold onto on the bottom and to push on the top. The contact stress in the mating gears is the key parameter in gear design. Mohammad jebran khan reports the contact stress analysis of stainless steel spur gears by theoretical method using hertz equations and by finite element analysis using fea software ansys 14. With catia, the parametric modeling at the interface of the roller and pallet is carried out. A free software application to calculate hertzian contact stress and point and line contact dimensions. For the contact patch dimensions a and b, i get the expression where i need to determine m and n. The price of flexbeam pro with its extensive functionality is 9. This paper is a revised and expanded version of an article entitled, contact stress analysis in wheelrail by hertzian method and finite element method presented in national conference on recent advancements in mechanical engineering held at north east regional institute of science and technology, arunachal pradesh. The contact pressure results are then verified by twindisc. The calculation is done using a tribology simulator software, which is available for download here its free to use.
Contact mechanics is the study of the deformation of solids that touch each other at one or more points. Stress analysis of helical gear by finite element method govind t sarkar1, yogesh l yenarkar 1 and dipak v bhope corresponding author. Now choose contact normal stress y, and then click ok. Hertz contact stress mechanical engineering general. It is difficult to get correct answer on gear tooth stress by implying fundamental stress equation, such as lewis formula for bending stress and hertz equation for contact stress. Aug 07, 2012 actually, i believe you will have to include the wheels in the analysis. For example, in mechanical engineering and tribology, hertzian contact stress is a description of the stress within mating parts. Keywordsbending stress, contact stress, lewis equation, hertz equation, spur gear. For calculating these contact stress and bending stress analysis of spur gear both material of pinion and gear is made of steel. The model of two elastic cylinders is widespread in imprinter inking system and other fields, but it is difficult to analysis the contact stress and the deformation with finite element analysis software. Herein, we report the contact stress analysis of stainless steel spur gears by theoretical method using hertz equations and by finite element analysis using fea software. Contact stress analysis and optimization of bevel gear.
I have a book which shows me every step, except for how to calculate two coefficients, and insteads gives me a table of calculated values. How do i simulate hertz stress that results from contact pressure. The solid model of railwheel contact model is created in catia v5. Dec 06, 2016 hertz contact theory hct is a study of contact stress and deformation which is widely used in many engineering fields. This paper presents a study by the finite element method fem of the contact tensions between two bodies and the results obtained are compared with the calculations obtained on basis of the relations of the theory of h. Prex could you please give me a reference for your advice the limits normally adopted for hertz s contact stresses are 4 times the allowable stress for linear contact and 5. Hertz contact stress analysis and validation using finite element. The material of both wheel and rail is steel and the friction coefficient is 0.
There is a dynamic discount 5% 15% for 5, 10, 20 en 50 users. Hertz contact stress analysis and validation using. The objective of this work is to calculate the contact stress by using hertz theory and compare with fem results. That is the only way to get reasonably accurate results. High contact stresses are always shown in one or two node locations. Buckling calculations are done for central load eulerformula and for. In the development phase, the contact stress analysis is carried out. The model is a simplified model of a train wheel on the rail. I made sure that mesh is good most of the elements that are part of the contact area has aspect ratio close to 1 and meshed with brick elements. This paper presents the stress analysis of mating teeth of spur gear to find maximum contact stress in the gear teeth.
Frictional contact stress analysis of spur gear by using finite element method. The finite element analysis software ansys workbench was used for this purpose. I dont find the wikepedia article very illuminating. Hertz contact problem describes the behavior of a steel cylinder pressed into an aluminium block. Jerome, france i use hertzwin to calculate contact stiffness. Apr 22, 20 step by step procedure of how to do static structural analysis of hertzian contact analysis ansys workbench. Peter, the netherlands i have downloaded your hertzwin program and have confirmed that your hertz contact stress calculation matches what i have been using. A central distinction in contact mechanics is between stresses acting perpendicular to the contacting bodies surfaces known as the normal direction and frictional stresses acting tangentially between the surfaces. Contact stress and shear stress analysis of spur gear using. My goal is to get consistent results with the analytical solu. Hertz contact theory is a classical theory of contact mechanics and is a powerful tool for engineers and researchers. Step by step procedure of how to do static structural analysis of hertzian contact analysis ansys workbench. Extended hertz theory of contact mechanics for case.
Contact stresses finite element analysis fea engineering. Bending stress and contact stress hertz stress calculation is the basic of stress analysis. Here in, we report the contact stress analysis of stainless steel spur gears by theoretical method using hertz equations and. The hertz contact theory is a study of the local stress and strain distribution. Dec 26, 2014 this paper discusses the hertz contact theory validation using finite element analysis. Since my cams are designed in excel using splines with xyz points exported to solidworks curves, i really need my excel calculations of stress to be accurate, so i strove to fix them. The contact area is small compared to the size of the bodies. Bharat gupta, et al 4 describes the contact stress analysis of spur gear. Welsim finite element analysis software helps engineers and. International journal of research in engineering, science. Contact stress and bending stress analysis of spur gear by.
Just enter the data and flexbeam instantaneously provides you with the outcome. Stress analysis of mating involute spur gear teeth ijert. Using hertz contact theory to calculate the contact stress and the deformation can save a lot of time. This paper presents the results of a study carried out using the finite element method, on the contact stresses between two bodies. The current goal is that the finite element analysis of the bevel gear is performed to. Applicability of the hertz contact theory to rolling. Applicability of the hertz contact theory to rolling rubber cylinders. Structural fea software rfem and the frame analysis program rstab perform stress analysis of 2d and 3d structures. Table4 compares the contact stress values obtained by using the hertz approach, agma and ansys for different modules. Contact stresses between two cylindrical bodies sciencedirect.
Keywords hertz contact stress, contact fe analysis, stresses. Cut the half circles vertically into quarter circles. Contact stress analysis of composite spur gear using photo. Simscale offers 3000 hours of computing per year for a free user. Contact stress and shear stress analysis of spur gear. This paper discusses the hertz contact theory validation using finite element analysis. Li xi, cao shihao and other 2 through hertz and finite element analysis software ansys,a study on the. Youngs modulus elasticity, also called elastic modulus of the cam and the camfollower n mm 2. Hertzian contact stress wolfram demonstrations project. The results obtained from finite element analysis fea are compared with theoretical hertzian equation values. Stress analysis has been a key area of research to minimize failure of the gear and optimize the design.
Pdf hertz contact stress analysis and validation using. Hertz contact stress calculations and graphs with hertzwin. Tutorial on hertz contact stress university of arizona. On this page the demo versions and the software documentation are available. Keywords hertz contact stress, contact fe analysis, stresses within rollers, roller contact analysis and. This kind of stress may not be significant most of the time, but may cause. Oct 15, 2016 i can strongly recommend the cloudbased simulation platform, simscale for stress analysis. Pitting is a surface fatigue failure due to repetitions of high contact stresses. The simulator uses a boundary element method bem with fast fourier transform and conjugate g. Pdf frictional contact stress analysis of spur gear by. When this happens, complex stresses are induced under the surface at the contact.
Hertz contact analysis in welsim welsim finite element. The study of contact stress developed between the mating gears are very important for the gear design. The pulley grooves wear interpret analytical form based on. In addition to normal and shear stress, you can also calculate contact stresses in rfem. I am performing contact stress analysis on an assmebly that has male and female mating parts similar to dovetail joint.
Hey, im modeling a hertz contact between a sphere and a rigid plane. When two bodies with curved surfaces are in contact under a force, point or line contact between these bodies. The problem is linear except for the contact condition between the two parts. Out of these, failure of gears due to contact stress is high compared to bending stress. There are several kinds of stresses present in loaded and rotating gear teeth. Contact stress analysis of spur gear for different. Actually, i believe you will have to include the wheels in the analysis. This paper presented analysis of bending stress and contact stress of involute spur gear teeth in meshing. Take largescale general finite element software ansys as the analysis tool and the cylindrical roller bearing as the research object, we establish the ideal contact numerical model of roller and analyze the hertz contact stress. Create a steel semicylinder with a radius of 5 is pressed against a 2 deep aluminum base. In 1882, hertz solved the contact problem of two elastic bodies with curved surfaces. This paper gives a finite element model for introspection of the stresses in the tooth. The present work is an attempt to find root bending stress distribution, maximum allowable contact stress and total.
This maximum contact stress value is almost identical with the values obtained by agma and lewis equations. As anthony said, learn about hertz contact stress before you try and run an analysis. Stress calculator software in hertz stress calculator the data. In this paper the bending stress over the lower addendum of the spur gear, shear and contact stresses by using the software tools like proe and ansys are employed to design and analysis.
Stress analysis on spur gears using ansys workbench 16. Moreover, previous studies primarily rely on extension of boussinesqs method, whereas practices in bearing industry have evolved to use of hertz equations for stress, deformation, and fatigue life calculations 7,8. The results are compared, following the analysis, to the results calculated on basis of the relations in h. Contact stress analysis of a helical gear scientific. Keywords hertz contact stress, contact fe analysis, stresses within rollers. The stress field under the surface is termed hertzian contact stress reference hertz 1881 has done the hard work to derive the equations we need to calculate the stress when there is contact between two bodies that are conformal or nonconformal. Modeling hertzian contact stress in line contact by two.
The main factors that cause the failure of gears are the bending stress and contact stress of the gear tooth. Contact stress analysis of spur gear for different materials. At first, a spur gear with perfect involute is modeled using a 3d cad software. I have also had good luck with the use of a free software package called hertzwin by an engineering firm named vink netherlands for very local linear hertz contact stress analysis. In a recently published contact mechanics challenge results, it was shown that bem based approach along with a computationally demanding greens functions approach is the most accurate way to calculate contact pressure for rough surfaces. Flexbeam is a userfriendly calculator for beam analysis. Applicability of the hertz contact theory to rolling rubber. N karthik bommisetty abstract a finite element procedure has been developed in this work to determine the load distribution factor, km, of the agma formula for a set of spur gear. The parameters that determine the hertzian contact stress are. Hertz contact stress analysis and validation using finite. Jan 23, 2020 an extremely high level of mesh refinement is typically needed to achieve a converged stress result in the hertzian contact area, so most customers use a 2d simplification study in solidworks simulation for this. This stillrelevant classical solution provides a foundation for modern problems in contact mechanics. From these above expressions, we can calculate principle stresses and maximum shear stress analysis of rail wheel contact stresses by using ansys ansys is finite element analysis software which enables engineers to perform the following tasks. You can immediately see, on one window, which load is calculated, the second moment of area and the resulting stress, deflection and slope.
Contact stress analysis of spur gear to optimize mass or. Contact stress distribution of large diameter ball bearing. Nov 28, 2014 this paper discusses the hertz contact theory validation using finite element analysis. Solidworks did, however, yield results very close to this free software. If your contact calculation is for a hertz contact stress, then neither inventor stress analysis isa nor incad are calculating an accurate contact stress with that coarse mesh. Contact stress analysis of hard coating rolling bearing. That calculation results of the ideal model are correspond to that of the finite element verifies the correctness of the finite element analysis method. A 2d plane strain model is a good idea, the half cylinders become half circles. Keywords hertz contact stress, contact fe analysis, stresses within rollers, roller contact analysis and hertz contact stress calculations. As finite element method fem is the easy and accurate technique for stress analysis, fea is done in finite element software abaqus. In rstab, stress analysis is performed for member cross. Stress analysis has been a key area of research to minimize failure and optimize design. My compliments for the userfriendliness and the visual feedback. The results obtained showed that difference between magnitude of the stresses for a given configuration of a spur gear and hertz contact stress, while.
Hertzs analysis of contact stress involves the following set of assumptions. Spur gear was modeled through parametric modelling in proe software. The hertz contact stress is highly localized, so you need an element size maybe 3 to 10 times smaller than the width of the contact area, and i think both meshes. These stresses were first studied by the german physicist heinrich hertz in 1881. We can also do wear analysis due to frictional rubbing between the contact. I need to write up my calcs and submit to my customer.
Contact analysis simplification contact problem definitions 6 267 r. Hertz contact stress is very localized, so you dont need a full cylinder, a half cylinder will do. However, the simulations project that are created is openly available for all users on. The stress that occurs at the contact between two bodies is known as hertzian contact stress, see reference paper above.
However, there are many limiting conditions for the applications of the hct, in this paper, the contact model between a plastic cylinder and a rubber cylinder does not fit two limiting conditions. These conditions require contact analysis of elastically graded materials under threedimensional 3d loading. Over a century ago hertz established a theory of contact mechanics that is still used today by engineers working in tribology to make his theory accessible for engineering applications the program calculates a fast and accurate solution this demonstration presents the hertzian contact stress distribution and elastic deformations it uses a color. To make his theory accessible for engineering applications, the program calculates a fast and accurate solution. Mechanical calculations contact stress, beam analysis. Im doing an analysis where i need to evaluate the contact area acoording to hertz theory. Trying the model the hertz contact behavior with the required, very small element sizes does not leave much processing capacity for modeling the global behavior. A short overview of the functionality of the rolling bearing analysis software. In this article, a calculation of contact pressure in a rough contact is discussed. The model is based on the halfspace theory approximation. The hertz contact theory the hertz contact theory consists of a series of mathematical equations to calculate normal, hoop, radial, and shear stress components on and within a soft flat surface or halfspace, known as the specimen, when pressed by a rigid hemisphere called the indentor appendix figure 1 1. The aim is to find the contact stress between rail and wheel. We can also do wear analysis due to frictional rubbing between the contact surfaces. Contact stress analysis of spur gear for different materials using ansys and hertz equation putti srinivasa rao1, nadipalli sriraj2, mohammad farookh2 1professor, dept.
856 1506 1029 813 462 1379 287 368 1007 1174 606 1275 31 1599 918 1462 1113 1382 1075 1002 1295 1658 1225 190 1273 1347 240 1349 1488 412 97 861 719 43 1362 827